The impact of payday loans market
There is mixed evidence on the impact of a derivatives market on its underlying asset market. Some studies have found a reduction in volatility after the introduction of derivatives while others conclude that volatility was not affected or even increased.
The general reasoning for an increase in payday loans volatility states that derivatives attract speculators who may destabilize the base market and create bubbles, and that the closing out of hedging positions shortly before expiration creates additional price variation. On the other hand, a decrease of volatility could result as derivatives make a market more complete, reduce transaction costs and enhance information flows. Also, the transfer of speculative activity from the base market to the derivative market may dampen volatility.
Others suggests that derivatives improve the efficiency of incomplete markets by expanding the opportunity set faced by investors. This in turn should reduce the volatility of the underlying asset. Research show that option listings have beneficial effects and improve the market quality and liquidity of the underlying stocks. They analyzed the impact of derivatives on their underlying assets for 174 stocks that had an option listed on either the American Stock Exchange (Amex), the Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE), the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), the Pacific Stock Exchange (PSE) or the Philadelphia Stock Exchange (PHLX) from 1983 to 1989. In particular, they observed a decrease in the bid-offer spreads and increases in quoted depth, trading volume, trading frequency and transaction size after the introduction of derivatives. In summary, the listing of options resulted in reduced transaction costs for the underlying stocks. Further, they found that information asymmetries decreased and pricing efficiency increased.
It is possible to make a credit funded investment
Alternatively to an unfunded swap or CFD, it is also possible to make a funded investment. Rather than paying LIBOR plus a spread quarterly and receiving property returns, the investor pays the notional amount of cash upfront and receives property returns net of the spread. For example, on a two-year swap an investor could choose, rather than paying LIBOR plus 1% on the swap, to pay 100% of the notional amount and receive the property return minus 1% each year and 100% redemption after two years.
The basis for property derivatives documentation is the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) documentation. Just as for other derivatives, ISDA has prepared standardized documents for property swaps, in order to facilitate trading. The Property Index Derivatives Definitions were published in May 2007. Standardization aims to reduce transaction costs, legal risk and transaction time, to increase transparency and confidence in the market, and to improve efficiency and liquidity. In addition to the definitions, ISDA provides confirmation templates for forwards and swaps in the US (Form X) and in Europe (Form Y), as well as an annex that describes the indices on which the trades are based. By September 2007, the Association has included the Standard&Poor’s/Case–Shiller Index, the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight (OFHEO) Index, the National Council of Real Estate Investment Fiduciaries (NCREIF) Index, the worldwide Investment Property Databank (IPD) Indices, the UK Halifax House Price Index, the FTSE UK Commercial Property Index and Radar Logic’s Residential Property Index (RPX). The definitions booklet covers issues such as disruption events on these indices. More indices, as well as confirmation templates for options and basket trades, are likely to follow.
Market participants report loan enquiries
The first French property swap was traded by Merrill Lynch and AXA Real Estate Investment Managers in December 2006. The undisclosed notional amount was linked to the IPD Total Return French Offices Annual Index. By mid 2007, the French market has developed a permanent two-way pricing, i.e. bid and offer prices are constantly quoted. By the end of the fourth quarter of 2007, GB£ 787 million have been transacted in 63 trades. Most trades have been done on the office component of the French IPD index.
Moreover, market participants report enquiries on derivatives relating to the National Institute for Statistics and Economic Studies (INSEE) residential house price index.
The first option on an IPD index outside the UK was traded in January 2007, referenced to the German IPD/DIX Index. Goldman Sachs acted as intermediary for this trade, which was one of the first property derivative transactions in Germany. Subsequently, BNP Paribas offered a capital protected note on a basket consisting of IPD UK All Properties, IPD France Offices and IPD Germany All Properties. IPD publishes official transaction data starting with the second quarter of 2007.
The market picked up quickly, with 44 trades on a total notional value of GB£ 283 million from the second to the fourth quarter of 2007. In May 2007, Deutsche Bank Research expects the German market to reach € 25 billion by 2010. HypoVereinsbank states that a volume of € 150 billion is possible in the long run for Germany and € 300 billion for the European Union.
The numbers represent about 1% of the respective physical property market.
Relative payday loans demand
The International Securities Exchange (ISE) launched a derivatives market based on the Rexx commercial real estate property indices in November 2006. The market will operate using the Longitude framework, a matching engine based on a Dutch auction process.
At the launch, a subset of the Rexx indices was chosen based on anticipated demand. For each index offered, a series of auctions was held prior to publishing the Rexx index, which allows market participants to trade digital and vanilla options as well as forward contracts on the index value.
The auction format differs from a traditional, continuously quoted market in several ways. Instead of requiring a discrete match between a buyer and a seller, the auction aggregates liquidity across all strikes and derivatives. The prices in the auction are determined by the relative demand represented by all the orders received up to that point. As the auction operates as a Dutch auction, all trades are cleared at the final auction market price, even if that market price is better than a trade’s limit price. According to ISE, auction participants include pension funds, commercial property managers, investment banks, hedge funds, portfolio managers, REITs and CMBS. Besides serving as an underlying part for the ISE platform, the Rexx index is also said to be used in the OTC market.
