Derivatives to manage house credit and price risk
On the side of residential owner-occupied housing, Hinkelmann and Swidler (2006) are sceptic as to whether the market can take off. Mentally, homeowners tend to treat their home just as a consumption good rather than as an investment that involves price risk. Moreover, they would always be subject to a huge tracking error risk when hedging their homes with derivatives based on house price indices. This limits the effectiveness of hedging, and individuals may not use derivatives to manage house price risk. Ultimately, a lack of hedgers in the marketplace may lead to failure of residential housing derivatives such as the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) housing futures contracts. It remains to be seen whether the involved challenges and hurdles can be successfully addressed.
History shows that the buildup period of a new market is very fragile. Property derivatives were launched in the early 1990s and actually failed. The debut on the London Futures and Options Exchange (FOX) crashed in a combination of bad timing and scandal over false trades designed to create the impression of higher activity (see experience in property derivatives).
Today, liquidity in the property derivatives market has a good chance of being increased. In 1981, the first interest rate swap was done. Although people were sceptic at the time, it is now a trillion dollar market. The property market could experience a similar sort of growth in derivative instruments.
Credit generates information about supply and demand
Property derivatives will improve transparency in the real estate market. According to Tsetsekos and Varangis (2000), an active derivatives market plays an important role in facilitating an efficient determination of prices in the underlying spot market by improving transparency on current and future prices. A successful property derivatives market may have several feedback effects on its underlying properties and indices.
Derivatives and their prices generate information about supply and demand of market participants. After the establishment of a derivatives market and due to more and better information, efficiency in the spot market can very well improve. Derivatives make nontransparent prices visible. In particular, the observed derivative prices reveal the market’s expectations. The result could be that market participants anticipate price expectations faster, and nonrandom price moves such as cyclical behavior could partly be washed out. It is important not to confuse true cycles with autocorrelation in an index that may simply arise due to the index construction method. It can be assumed that prices of physical properties adapt faster to new information if there is a derivatives market.
